Goldman Sachs Group Inc (GS  ) Chief Executive Officer David Solomon has navigated a path filled with both triumphs and tribulations.

His leadership style, marked by a blend of intensity and rigor, has led to a series of successes but also sparked internal dissent.

Now, a provocative question has been raised in a New York Magazine article: "Is David Solomon Too Big a Jerk to Run Goldman Sachs?"

Twice rejected by Goldman Sachs before finally securing a position in 1999, Solomon's ascent within the firm was anything but smooth. His leadership, characterized by a demanding and sometimes abrasive approach, has been a subject of both admiration and concern, New York Magazine reports.

Progressive Policies and Internal Conflicts

Upon assuming the role of CEO in 2018, Solomon implemented progressive policies, including relaxed dress codes and diversity initiatives. However, his unyielding pursuit of ambitious goals and his unwillingness to tolerate failure led to internal conflicts and a series of high-profile departures.

Questionable Decisions and Public Persona

Despite achieving the highest profits in Goldman's history in 2021, Solomon's recent decisions and management style have attracted criticism. His aggressive expansion into consumer banking, coupled with his public persona as a DJ, has raised questions about his focus and judgment.

The Marcus Division and Leadership Doubts

Solomon's handling of the Marcus consumer division and the subsequent financial challenges have further fueled doubts about his leadership. The division's struggles and Solomon's reaction to dissent have left many questioning whether his approach is suitable for the firm's future.

Legacy and Uncertainty

Since Solomon's tenure began, over 200 partners have exited the firm, and his recent efforts to reconnect with the partners through various events have not fully healed the divisions.

Wells Fargo's Mike Mayo sees the situation differently, attributing the unrest more to discontented traders than to Solomon's leadership flaws. Despite acknowledging recent setbacks in consumer banking and earnings, Mayo maintains that Goldman Sachs still stands strong among its rivals. His perspective was shared on Bloomberg's Surveillance, Bloomberg reports.

Leadership Transition at Goldman Sachs

Meanwhile, John Rogers, known as the "CEO Whisperer" at Goldman Sachs, is stepping down after nearly 30 years. He passes his role as chief of staff to Russell Horwitz, a former Goldman executive. Rogers will retain positions including executive vice president and leader of philanthropic efforts. Horwitz, once chief of staff to former Goldman CEO Lloyd Blankfein, will rejoin Goldman as Solomon's new chief of staff, following his role as chief global affairs officer at Citadel.